Anyone else read this recent article in the National Post about Oprah and her book club? It's written by Ted Rall, a hard-hitting, take-no-prisoners editorial cartoonist and writer in the US. Sometimes I disagree with Ted's views, but most of time, I like what he has to say. And I gotta admit, I agree with his views on Oprah and her book club. And they're not very nice.
If you're interested in the subject of the article, I urge you to read the whole piece. But basically what Ted is saying is that Oprah has a big part to play in the quality of books that get attention in the media, specifically some of the questionable 'memoirs' that Oprah has been raving about (and then running away from) in the past few years:
Oprah claims she was duped by greedy, lazy publishers. Yet, her web-site still recommends the fake books by Frey and the Rosenblats. Even so, the problem isn't Oprah's credulousness. It's that she has atrocious taste. That, and a platform for promoting her bad taste.
Rall goes on to say:
The problem isn't bad and dishonest writers. They can't help themselves. The problem is that mainstream American culture is gullible, sentimental and dumb.
No one is more blameworthy for Americans' stupidity than publishers and book reviewers who act as taste-makers. As in all creative pursuits, publishing exposure is a zero-sum game. Rising tides don't lift all boats; anyway, they're more like thrones than tides. A few titles suck the air out of the room as the rest wither and die due to lack of attention.
Each decision to review a bad book results in a better book going unreviewed, unnoticed and its author unremunerated -- and thus less likely to publish more books. Each prize committee's decision to grant an award to a bad book takes away praise that might otherwise have drawn acclaim and sales to a good one. When bad books do well, authors study what works in the marketplace and copy the formula-- resulting in more bad books.
Readers who rely on popular hype to choose books often come away disappointed. A few may decide to dig deeper, but most won't. Burned readers become non-readers.
Yup, I gotta admit, that pretty much sums up my view of Oprah and her book club these days. And yeah, I know what the retort to that statement is: "But she's getting people reading!" And yes, I'll concede that that is a good thing. But – if she's just getting people (and I mean a LOT of people) reading crap, which in turn motivates publishers to produce more and more crap, then quite frankly, I wish she'd just stop that damn book club and go back to talking about her weight problems exclusively.
Confession: When Oprah first started her book club, I was excited. I read quite a few of the books on her list: The Deep End of the Ocean, The Book of Ruth, She's Come Undone, Stones From the River, Here on Earth, I Know This Much Is True, The Pilot's Wife and Middlesex (actually, I read that one long before Oprah recommended it on her club. Hmmm). Save for Middlesex, I would say that pretty much all those titles are not really impressive books. In fact, some of them are downright awful. I certainly would not go back and reread any of those novels (and quite frankly, I wish I could take back all the time it took for me to read I Know This Much Is True. Gawd). Over time I stopped reading Oprah's recommendations because I was getting mighty sick of reading another heart-breaking story about some down-trodden woman finding her way in the unjust world. I think she picked up on this response from the general public, and that's when she surprised everyone (including Jonathan Franzen) by picking The Corrections for one of her book club recommendations. Well, we all know how that story panned out. And now the latest drama in her book club picks is her love of the gut-wrenching memoir, which as her luck would have it, keeps turning out to be a crock of shit. Enough, already, Oprah. It was a good run. Sort of. Now. Please. Stop. Save us from yourself.
And so, my BiblioQueria question to you is...
What's your take on Oprah's book club? Love it? Hate it?
And as a special treat, for those who've never seen these strips (and those who'd like a trip down memory lane) a couple of links to my 'Art Imitating Lit' comics, all about Oprah. Warning, though, for those who haven't encountered my comic strip humour before: they contain a lot of potty words.
A Million Literary Pickles
The Story of 'O'